📈 Stay up to date with the latest startup, technology and commercial law insights from Allied Legal Follow on LinkedIn

Do I need a shareholders agreement? If your company has two or more shareholders, the answer is almost always yes. No Australian law requires one. But without one, your rights depend on the Corporations Act, the replaceable rules and your company constitution, and nobody drafted those rules for your business. This guide explains what applies by default, what a shareholders agreement adds, and when to put one in place.
No. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) does not require a company to have a shareholders agreement. ASIC lists it as an optional document. A company must have a constitution, rely on the replaceable rules, or use a mix of both.
So the real question is not whether the law demands one. The real question is whether you can live with the default rules if your co-owners disagree.
Without a shareholders agreement, your company runs on the Corporations Act, the replaceable rules and any constitution. These documents cover the basics. The constitution and replaceable rules also work as a contract between the company and each member, and between the members themselves.
Under the replaceable rules, shareholders usually appoint and remove directors by ordinary resolution, which needs a simple majority. Directors decide whether the company pays dividends. Existing shareholders also get a default right to take up new share issues in proportion to their holdings. That right does not cover transfers between shareholders and outsiders. Our guide to pro rata rights explains how this works in practice.
These defaults suit a company with one owner. They work poorly for a company with several. A 51% shareholder can usually appoint and remove every director, so a minority shareholder may have little say. The law does offer relief from shareholder oppression, but a court application is an expensive last resort, not a plan.
A constitution also binds members, so the two documents overlap. The differences are practical.
A constitution binds the company and its members. A shareholders agreement binds only the people who sign it, and it usually includes the company. Shareholders can change a constitution by special resolution, which needs 75% of the votes cast. They can change a shareholders agreement only if every party agrees. A shareholders agreement also stays between its parties, and nobody needs to lodge it with ASIC.
A shareholders agreement cannot override the law. It cannot excuse directors from their statutory duties, and it cannot change the solvency test for dividends. Directors must still act in good faith and in the best interests of the company, whatever the agreement says.
Many companies use both documents. The constitution sets the corporate rules, and the shareholders agreement sets the commercial deal between the owners. Read our guide to the company constitution and replaceable rules for more on how they fit together. Make sure the two documents do not conflict, and state which one prevails if they do.
A good agreement deals with the issues that cause disputes. Most cover four areas.
The agreement can give each shareholder the right to nominate a director, often only while they hold a minimum percentage. It can also list reserved matters that need more than a simple majority. Common examples include issuing shares, borrowing money and selling the business. These are contractual rights. The agreement works by binding each party to vote their shares in a particular way.
Founders can record who contributes cash, time or intellectual property, and what happens if someone stops contributing. Vesting can tie a founder’s shares to their continued work. Our guide to founder vesting explains the options.
A dividend policy can set out when the company intends to pay dividends. Directors still decide each dividend. The Corporations Act also limits payments. A company can pay a dividend only if three conditions hold. Its assets must exceed its liabilities by a sufficient margin. The payment must be fair to shareholders as a whole. It must not materially prejudice the company’s ability to pay creditors. A dividend policy cannot override that test.
Transfer clauses control who can become a shareholder. A pre-emption clause makes a departing shareholder offer shares to the others first. Under a tag-along clause, minority shareholders can sell on the same terms when a majority sells. Drag-along clauses let a majority require the minority to join a sale to a buyer.
Exit clauses cover death, incapacity, retirement and the sale of the company. Default clauses cover a shareholder who breaches the agreement, for example by leaving early. Draft default clauses with care. A court may treat a forced sale at a steep discount as a penalty. That risk arises when the detriment is out of all proportion to the company’s legitimate interest. The High Court set that test in Paciocco v ANZ. Our guide to a smooth shareholder exit covers the main options.
Owners with equal shares risk deadlock, where neither side can win a vote. The agreement can set a path for resolving it, usually negotiation, then mediation, then a buy-sell mechanism. In a shotgun clause, one party names a price and the other must either buy or sell at that price. Our guide to the 50/50 split explains the risks.
Put one in place at the start, before anything is worth fighting over. At incorporation, everyone is friendly and nobody knows who will benefit from the terms. That makes the terms fairer. Later, each owner negotiates with something to lose.
Several events call for an agreement:
Startups face extra risks, because founders and investors want different things. Our article on why every startup needs a shareholders agreement covers those risks.
You can still sign an agreement after the company has issued shares. The difficulty is that every shareholder must agree. A shareholder who stands to lose rights has little reason to sign. A later constitutional change that adds new transfer restrictions generally cannot bind an existing member without that member’s written consent.
Use tailored advice rather than a template. A template cannot reflect your funding, your roles or your exit plans. Review the agreement at each funding round and whenever ownership changes. Balance protection for minority shareholders against the need to make decisions quickly. A veto over every minor decision can freeze a business.
Our broader guide to shareholders agreements explains the key terms in more detail.
1. Is a shareholders agreement legally required in Australia?
No. The Corporations Act does not require one. A company must have a constitution, rely on the replaceable rules, or use both. Most companies with more than one shareholder still benefit from a shareholders agreement, because it covers matters the default rules do not address.
2. Can I put a shareholders agreement in place after the company has shareholders?
Yes. Every shareholder who will be a party must agree and sign. Signing is easier early, before any dispute arises, so act as soon as you notice the gap.
3. Does a shareholders agreement override the Corporations Act?
No. The agreement cannot change mandatory rules. Directors must still comply with their statutory duties, and a company must still meet the solvency test before it pays a dividend. The agreement can add to the default rules, but it cannot override the law.
4. What is the difference between a shareholders agreement and a company constitution?
A constitution sets the company’s internal rules and binds the company and its members. A shareholders agreement binds only its parties and records the commercial deal between the owners. Shareholders can change a constitution by special resolution, but they can change a shareholders agreement only with every party’s agreement.
5. What happens if we fall out and have no shareholders agreement?
The replaceable rules, any constitution and the Corporations Act decide the outcome. A majority shareholder usually controls the board, and a minority shareholder may have to rely on court remedies such as an oppression claim. That route is slow and costly, and a shareholders agreement can avoid it.
Allied Legal drafts and reviews shareholders agreements for Australian startups and private companies. We align the agreement with your constitution, and we build in the vesting, transfer and exit terms that suit your business. If a dispute has already started, our shareholder dispute lawyers can advise on your options.
Learn more about our shareholders agreement service, or contact us on 03 8691 3111 / hello@alliedlegal.com.au.
This article is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should obtain legal advice specific to your circumstances before acting on any information contained in this article.